Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 2, 2022 14:36:24 GMT
There have been threads for all the other albums so I decided to start one for Voyage
1. I Still Have Faith in You/Keep and Eye on Dan 2. Don't Shut Me Down/Ode to Freedom 3. Just a Notion/No Doubt About It 4. When You Danced With Me/Little Things
I would have released single 1, months before the announcement of a new album. Single 2 at the September launch in September 2021. Whoever was leading on the A side, the other singer leading on the B side. There's also a musical contrast between both sides.
Single 3 a few weeks before Voyage was released - two uptempo songs which most casual fans probably prefer from ABBA. Finally, the final one for Christmas. Musically WYDWM is a bit festive and LT relegated to a B side (and not on the album!)
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 5, 2022 18:12:02 GMT
Until very recently I too thought releasing JAN as a single was a mistake. But I am not so sure it was now.
WYDWM got a lot of streams that it made the charts albeit a low position. If it was a single with CD and radioplay it could have done quite well.
I don't regard NDAI as a proper single as it wasn't available physically. Its release to radio didn't help with its streams or revive Voyage.
|
|
|
Post by gamleman on Oct 5, 2022 19:28:19 GMT
I don't really like too many singles (A-sides and B-sides) from an album, especially when there are only 10 songs on the album.
My selection would be similar to yours, Johnny, but with some tweaks...
1. I Still Have Faith in You/I Still Have Faith in You [Instrumental] 2. Don't Shut Me Down/Don't Shut Me Down [Extended Version] 3. Just a Notion/Just A Notion [Original 1979 Version] 4. When You Danced With Me/Little Things
I would have released 1 and 2 at the same time, as they did, as I thought that was a good move - ISHFIY is not typical single material (especially nowadays) and needed the more up-tempo DSMD as a counterpart.
I have included an instrumental (or Karaoke) of ISTHFIY, as I think it is an inspirational song that many people will want to sing themselves, in whatever setting.
Ideally, LT would have been a non-album B-side, with something else to take its place on the album. Actually, I would have preferred an extended version of WYDWM instead of LT, or the three of them as a 12-inch single / maxi CD-single, perhaps even with an up-tempo mix of LT too.
Had B&B been kind enough to include JLT on the album, that would have been my third single instead of JAN, with an alternative version of JLT as the B-side.
As far as I'm concerned, OTF is too classy to be included on a single.
|
|
|
Post by HOMETIME on Oct 5, 2022 20:20:21 GMT
Yes, that's my issue too: four singles from a 10-track album is enough, without pillaging the rest of the tracklist for B-sides. I like that people have suggested instrumental versions of ISHFIY as a B-side. In the 80s, instrumental mixes were very lazy B-sides. With this song, however, there are so many layers that an orchestral instrumental could be beautiful. Or even a very stripped acoustic version. I wonder what alternative takes of the tracks are in the vaults?
For what it's worth, my four A-sides would be I Still Have Faith In You, Don't Shut Me Down, No Doubt About It and (for no other reason than it proved a very radio friendly release), Just A Notion. The album tracks are all too good to have been squandered as B-sides. Yes, even Little Things!
|
|
|
Post by Anneke on Jan 15, 2023 18:24:04 GMT
ISHFIY isn't single material. As Benny puts it: it's not commercial. The problem with Voyage is that there are no singles on it except for DSMD
|
|
|
Post by HOMETIME on Jan 15, 2023 19:37:27 GMT
It's also Benny's favourite ABBA song right now, and he/ABBA were keen to make a single of it. I guess the thing with ABBA now is that they don't have to play by the commercial rules of old: they can release anything that they feel represents them. I heard DSMD on radio a fair bit at the time but - and I'm sure I wasn't imagining it - I heard JAN far more. BBC Radio 2 seemed very keen on it.
I still think that they missed a trick by not issuing ISHFIY and DSMD separately. And DSMD should definitely have been given a proper video. If things go well for ABBA at the Grammys, I wonder if they might reactivate DSMD as a single?
|
|
|
Post by AdamDawson2003 on Jan 15, 2023 23:08:56 GMT
I Still Have Faith In You/Ode To Freedom Don't Shut Me Down/No Doubt About It Just A Notion/Bumblebee When You Danced With Me/Little Things I Can Be That Woman/Keep An Eye On Dan
I adore 'When You Danced With Me' and think it should have been released as a single in place of 'No Doubt About It' which is a good song and it would have been interesting to have seen how 'I Can Be That Woman' would have faired had it been released as a single.
I love all the songs on 'Voyage' including 'Ode To Freedom' it still needs to grow on me I like every song that ABBA have ever recorded there isn't one song I dislike.
I actually think ABBA made a mistake with making 'The Day Before You Came' an A Side I would have flipped it and had 'Cassandra' as the A Side for two reasons its a better song and its classic ABBA and very catchy they made the perfect choice releasing 'Under Attack' as a single its an excellent song and one of their most underrated songs its in my top 10 favourite ABBA songs.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 16, 2023 9:35:07 GMT
In retrospect it was a mistake to have NDAI as a radio only single. It is clear from comments from a Universal executive they thought ABBA would win that BRIT award and coupled with airplay revive Voyage's fortunes. It is ABBA's least streamed song despite being very uptempo. It's just not popular.
I am not a fan of Little Things but if you have a Christmas song I guess you have to release it. It's an odd choice as album track.
I know ABBA getting to the Top 10 with DSMD was a great achievement and very unusual for veteran acts BUT it could have done even better
1. No announcement/leaks about new album until DSMD had charted 2. A proper video 3. A vinyl version 4. 'Spoken' intro edited out.
I think the focus on that September day was all the new album and show and the songs were just promotion. No emphasis on physical versions it was all about streaming the songs.
|
|
|
Post by foreverfan on Jan 16, 2023 10:29:02 GMT
^^^adamdawson2003...
If my memory is still good ..lol I distinctly remember , and it must have been UK radio 1 at the time, flipping TDBYC To Cassandra, it may have been only that once , or it may have been more,but it was highly unusual to play a B side, whether it was desperation from the record company or Radio 1 trying to boost the flagging fortunes of TDBYC,but It happened... The last time I remember a B side being promoted was Boney Ms Brown Girl In The Ring, Which was very successful, I guess there must have been more, but they allude at the moment.
Cassandra at the time was more “ typical” ABBA, and although not really single material, it’s a good track, it still failed to revive TDBYC...
As regarding tracks from Voyage, all in hindsight now, and it surprises me really that mistakes by the record company were made after all these years with ABBA, or were they ? As much as I like ISHFIY , it wasn’t single material, then now or even in the past, full of sentiment and the correct meaning but not really single material.
DSMD, another story, great track and approved across the board, but no video, how stupid was that, it’s not as if they hadn’t time to create one, it’s rumoured that it may get a repromotion due to the Grammys, I doubt it though unless it comes with something special....It really should have been a stand alone single.....
Once the album was released , any other track was going to find it tough to be a hit single, as much as I like JAN, it was to late, everyone had the album who wanted it, why download/buy the single, a few 1000 sales at the most.
We all know what we think of LT, personally if it had been uptempo, fantastic and probably would have been top 10, but didn’t crack the top 50, and as for 2022 Christmas I For one never heard it once on the radio and I listen for about 6 hours a day. As mentioned it may have stood a better chance if it had been a stand alone track.
Was there another track that should’ve been a single, well we all have our thoughts, but as stated once Voyage was released another hit wasn’t going to happen......I understand airplay awareness ,but I’m guessing record companies still want Hits, regardless of what ABBA want and NDAI did nothing for itself let alone the album, as much as it’s a great little track. Sometime less is more... two singles at the most, one to promote before and one to accompany the album release.......
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 16, 2023 11:10:45 GMT
Yes, once Voyage was released there were never going to be further hits from it. I am not convinced JAN or LT actually helped Voyage's sales. Its sales were very likely be front loaded - as proved and contuining stready until Christmas.
Announcing a new album when releasing the two new songs hampered their chart performances. People would just wait for the new album.
|
|
|
Post by richard on Jan 16, 2023 11:51:02 GMT
When I used to buy singles (how long ago it seems to me now), I can remember, even then, quite often thinking that the B-side was as good as, or as worth listening to, as the A-side. Nowadays, I don't draw a distinction in my mind between what was an A-side, B-side, or album track from a favourite group back then when listening to their songs now.
But if I tried to stick to the remit of this thread, I'd fail, especially if adhering to old commercial considerations. Probably it would be just one: Don't Shut Me Down/Just A Notion. Otherwise, it would be the no-surprise choice: DSMD/ISHFIY.
|
|
|
Post by joseph on Jan 16, 2023 16:53:04 GMT
Not sure why Little Things gets such a bashing. Sure, it's not my favourite by a long shot and Christmas itself can get in the bin. I like the Matt Pop mix but since when has every Christmas song supposed to be uptempo? Many aren't. For what it is, Little Things is a sweet little ditty, unfairly maligned.
|
|
|
Post by jj on Jan 16, 2023 18:09:01 GMT
Not sure why Little Things gets such a bashing. I agree, it's really nice and has an extremely catchy melody. Recently it's even become an earworm. Over the past couple of weeks, I can't stop hearing it in my head, and i can't get rid of it for at least an hour whenever it strikes.
|
|
|
Post by Henry on Jan 16, 2023 20:59:25 GMT
The original plan was to release DSMD as the second single. There would have been a video. Universal probably got cold feet over ISHFIY. universal hotshots decided to release both songs at the same time. The release of the singles and album were full of mistakes. LT isn't a single but a sweet album track. NDAI is not popular with the general audience but they released it as a radio single. I understand that the ladies didn't do promotion but appear in a video and a tv special isn't to much to ask. The problem is that the focus was on the show and not so much on the album. And that dreadful albumcover? I was very disappointed by this release and still am.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 16, 2023 21:33:58 GMT
I agree with most of the above apart from the last sentence. I am happy with Voyage. It's not ABBA's best and some songs I don't like. But overall more positivee and a few great songs.
|
|
|
Post by richard on Jan 17, 2023 15:41:01 GMT
Pity, but it seem to be true: some people's attention spans are so pathetically short that they maybe can't accept a few seconds for the preamble to DSMD to set the scene and brilliantly enhance the impact of the first verse when it enters. (Perhaps the acapella opening to Super Trouper - as with DSMD, it's the chorus melody slowed down - should be edited out for the same reason?!)
|
|
|
Post by Alan on Jan 17, 2023 17:20:36 GMT
And that dreadful albumcover? I was very disappointed by this release and still am. I love the album cover! There’s an elegance about it. Things like that will be a matter of personal taste though, and never going to please everyone. The poster that came with both the CD and vinyl was a bit of a waste of time however. The alternate album cover with the four ABBATar squares was OK but a little bit dark.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 17, 2023 17:43:31 GMT
Yep people have short attention spans. I guess most casual ABBA fans prefer the instant poppy hits. DSMD does take a while to get to that very catchy chorus.
Longer version on album (for "real" fans), shorter on single for casual fans.
Edited singles have been done before such as SNC, Eagle and The Visitors. And to be honest most ABBA singles got to the chorus quicker than DSMD. If in 1974 they waited over a minute and a half to get to the chorus for Waterloo they never would have won that contest.
Front cover. I don't like it. I prefer the alternate Tron one. Actually I wouldn't have minded seeing ABBA as they were in 2021. I liked the one in the catsuits and the one in the snow.
People are more photogenic when young or old - not middle aged. Sadly.
The Voyage singles How many did people buy? And where - Amazon, Abba Voyage site, HMV/record shop?
I got the first two only. CDs not vinyl version of ISHFIY. Ordered from Amazon. DSMD took quite a while to arrive. At about £6 each and no B side not good value for money. But it was ABBA.
|
|
|
Post by Alan on Jan 17, 2023 18:00:20 GMT
The only single I ever saw in HMV was Little Things, they had stacks of them in more than one store. They tended to display it next to the album, and £3.99 for a one-track single next to a £9.99 album (or however much the album was at that point) was a no-brainer. Why would a non-fan buy a single when they can buy a whole album containing not only that track but nine others?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 17, 2023 18:08:08 GMT
They should have just stuck to releasing the first two singles on CD and before any announcement of an album.
|
|
|
Post by Alan on Jan 17, 2023 18:26:44 GMT
Not sure that’s realistic though? Any single released by any act usually has a parent album ready. There was too much speculation about a full album for them not to announce that. I’d have been very disappointed if they’d not revealed the album from the start. And it was a full two months before the album release date, which is a long time.
No, I’m happy with things as they were. Little Things as a single may not have been the best idea but there was an inevitability about that. They weren’t going to hide a seasonal song on the album. Perhaps should have been single-only, but then it would have needed another track for the album. A nine-track album when each one was as short as it was wouldn’t have been good enough.
|
|
|
Post by richard on Jan 17, 2023 18:44:12 GMT
Just to add about edited pop recordings...
As someone whose music listening isn't confined to pop, such editing - for basically non-musical reasons, I'd argue -of already quite short songs amazes me and, for me, amounts the musical equivalent of fast, not very nutritious, food. But I admit my derogatory description is more applicable to pop songs of the late 50s and the 60s, at least in terms of their duration. And yet I have many favourites from that period! I suppose it boils down to whether one thinks the integrity of the song is spoilt by such editing. But of course to decide about that, it's necessary to hear the pre-edited version as well!
|
|
|
Post by richard on Jan 17, 2023 22:36:19 GMT
If you might be referencing my posts, Abracadabra. - I wasn''t implying 'butchering' - that wasn't my point, just to make it clear. I was talking about what I regard as unnecessary editing of already short enough songs (imo).
|
|
|
Post by Alan on Jan 18, 2023 8:33:29 GMT
I didn’t think it was? Not in the UK anyway. And the video has the full version. The first time the shorter version appeared in the UK was The Singles (which somehow I never noticed at the time) then in the original version of Gold.
|
|
|
Post by HOMETIME on Jan 18, 2023 8:53:08 GMT
I don't think the edit was released as a single anywhere? Perhaps it was a radio edit released only to broadcasters to appease radio presenters anxious about the running time? The first time I heard that edit of TNOTG was on a US compilation called The Magic Of ABBA, which I got in the summer of 1982. Voulez-Vous was also edited for that set. I gave the LP away many years ago, so I can't say whether the VV edit is different to the one on Gold or whether it matched the video.
The next time I heard that NOTG edit was on The Singles - The First Ten Years. Hard to say whether it was deliberately included to make the vinyl sound its best. It's the sort of thing that other artists/labels would include as a bonus track for collectors on an expanded reissue these days.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 18, 2023 10:34:01 GMT
The only singles (I think) that were edited were the ones I mentioned SNC (everywhere) Eagle (mainland Europe), The Visitors (USA) The Name of the Game, to my knowledge only edited on compilations. And GGG video is edited.
Don't Shut Me Down could have joined that list.
|
|
|
Post by gazman on Jan 18, 2023 12:56:41 GMT
The 'Gimme Gimme Gimme' single was edited in North America. Not sure about Canada, but in the US it failed to chart.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 18, 2023 13:23:50 GMT
Ok. I didn't know that. I am guessing that unnecessary bridge section.
|
|
|
Post by richard on Jan 18, 2023 14:14:17 GMT
[...] that unnecessary bridge section. This is the problem. What to edit out; what's deemed of no great loss if not heard; what's unnecessary? Intros, instrumental breaks, transitions, outros - plenty of opportunities to knock a minute off here and there to help those who find it difficult to listen to the rare 5-minute pop song. That said, some pop songs make me feel they're padded out even at 3 minutes! And I'm with those who think IIWFTN should have been a single, but needed editing because it does go on a bit. So in the end it's not about a pop song's duration, in and of itself - or shouldn't be (we're talking a few seconds in the grand scheme of things) - but whether it works. And we often won't agree about that either, I imagine!
|
|
|
Post by gazman on Jan 18, 2023 16:02:27 GMT
Ok. I didn't know that. I am guessing that unnecessary bridge section. The below is from Wikipedia - one or two extra interesting facts about GGG here too.... ************* The single version of this song, which was released in its full length of 4:48 everywhere else in the world, was released in the United States and Canada in an edited format, being just 3:36 in length. This was done by removing the first half of the opening instrumental, the first four of the eight bars of the instrumental bridge between the second and final chorus, and fading the song out early. It is believed[by whom?] the edit was done by Atlantic, ABBA's North American record label and not Polar, hence the reason why it was available only in the US and Canada. This single version has never appeared on any commercial CD issued by Polar/Universal to date and along with the US promo edit of "Chiquitita", it marked the only time Atlantic ever commercially released an edited version of an ABBA single while they had the North American rights to release ABBA recordings. As of September 2021, it is ABBA's tenth-biggest song in the UK, including both pure sales and digital streams.[4] The single was never released by Polar Music in the group's native Sweden, instead being featured on the Greatest Hits Vol. 2 album, which did get a Swedish release. While Polar released the single in neighbouring Norway, Denmark, and Finland, copies of these versions were not made available in the Swedish record stores, who thus arranged to import copies of the United Kingdom version on Epic Records. Sales of these imports were sufficient for the single to reach no. 16 on the sales chart in Sweden.
|
|