|
Post by voyage2 on May 25, 2023 9:13:38 GMT
I'm not going to be too popular with this opinion!! I don't think ABBA should appear at Eurovision next year, certainly not on stage, performing or speaking. We have to remember that this is not their night surely? If ABBA appear, that will be the only thing in the news, forget the winner!!?? There could be I suppose a small segment with maybe Bjorn saying good luck, but he did do that this year so why??
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 25, 2023 9:22:29 GMT
|
|
|
Post by foreverfan on May 25, 2023 9:52:51 GMT
Boooo Come on Benny pull something out the bag for a final time for the fans and we would all be happy to say goodbye ( well most of us ) and you can get back to BAO...
It's the perfect time to say a final goodbye and enjoy the rest of their lives......
|
|
|
Post by justabba on May 25, 2023 11:26:13 GMT
Gosh it looks like they had a row!
|
|
|
Post by richard on May 25, 2023 13:25:31 GMT
I think that for Benny it's maybe more about the money than the music nowadays when it comes to ABBA. (And, by the way, I've no objection to already rich people acquiring still more money.) I can certainly see how it would be a no-no for ABBA to present a new song at the 2024 ESC, for example. So it'll probably end up with one or more of them doing a short video wishing the contestants good luck in the 50th year "we won it".
I'm guessing BAO means more to Benny in terms of his musical life now; and maybe he regards ABBA-related activities as an occasional and reluctantly-accepted obligation. So I won't hold my breath in the hope Benny will do anything new musically with ABBA for their 50th anniversary.
|
|
|
Post by voyage2 on May 25, 2023 19:46:30 GMT
I should imagine Benny is thinking "what more do people want?! We released a new album in late 2021 and an Avatar experience in 2022 for our actual 50th Anniversary, do we now have to do something for every bloody anniversary!? 50th year since this, that and the other"! Lol! Even if they did something else, people would still ask for more!
They have gone out on a high, that hype generally won't be repeated.
I personally am very happy and satisfied with the success of Voyage and the only thing I can see that could happen is, if the 2, (at the time of Voyage's release), unfinished songs are really good, they possibly could release them as part of a deluxe edition of Voyage, therefore no pressure on chart positions!
This is in no way a criticism of people hoping for more! Just my thoughts!
|
|
|
Post by bennybjorn on May 25, 2023 21:14:03 GMT
I should imagine Benny is thinking "what more do people want?! We released a new album in late 2021 and an Avatar experience in 2022 for our actual 50th Anniversary, do we now have to do something for every bloody anniversary!? 50th year since this, that and the other"! Lol! Even if they did something else, people would still ask for more! They have gone out on a high, that hype generally won't be repeated. I personally am very happy and satisfied with the success of Voyage and the only thing I can see that could happen is, if the 2, (at the time of Voyage's release), unfinished songs are really good, they possibly could release them as part of a deluxe edition of Voyage, therefore no pressure on chart positions! This is in no way a criticism of people hoping for more! Just my thoughts! In all fairness it was Benny's own son, Ludwig, who started this discussion/rumour, saying how much they enjoyed writing and recording new songs together, and questioning why they wouldn't continue in some way. Then Bjorn said they were looking at creative ways of celebrating the 50th anniversary of Eurovision, and not just rereleasing stuff. So, it's not the fault of the fans for this recent speculation. But, yes, releasing the two unfinished songs would be nice, even if part of a deluxe package.
|
|
|
Post by foreverfan on May 26, 2023 9:26:44 GMT
^^ I guess " we" could argue that the two unfinished tracks are not new music ..to them....
I'm only guessing, but there seems to be a lot of conflicting messages, has Bjorn jumped the gun again as in previous posts, is Benny just being Benny and of course nothing from the girls...
It could all be part of the " game" they play with the media, and "Us " of course who just love to speculate.
Personally, happy with Voyage album, but rarely play whole album now ? What does that say.... Over the moon and back regarding Voyage Show, it really does do everything it says , a real must for those fans like us and hope we all get to see it just once.. I believe Joesph is going soon ? As with all of us it will be interesting to hear his perspective.....
So would I be happy with that being it .... in one way we have to be, out of our control, but do I really think that they will let the 50th go past with nothing..no... what that will be will be rumours and speculation for the next year. as I said before would be truly happy for a final hurrah, in whatever form it takes, even a thankyou and goodbye...
If it doesn't happen so be it....
One of my favourite sayings come around again....
We wait and See....
|
|
|
Post by richard on May 26, 2023 10:39:00 GMT
It seemed to me a rather low energy, almost disinterested, interview from Bjorn, as if he had talked about Voyage too many times. Or maybe he was feeling a bit under the weather.
Regarding his point-blank ruling out of any new music from ABBA - however 'new' might be interpreted - could there still be a smidgen of hope that they might be holding back to surprise us one last time? In an attempt to dampen down speculation a bit, Bjorn is hardly going to say "There might be something in the pipeline, music-wise, to celebrate our 50th anniversary of winning Eurovision. And then, of course, that really will be it".
I know - clutching at straws.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 26, 2023 14:18:46 GMT
Personally, happy with Voyage album, but rarely play whole album now ? What does that say... Happy it was released and did well.But that the novelty has worn off and realisation it is a patchy album.
|
|
|
Post by foreverfan on May 26, 2023 15:12:52 GMT
^^^Johnny.. Ironically it could just be the length between TV and V... 40 years of hope was perhaps to long.. if those 40 years had been scattered say every 10, with odd track or album, who knows.... Ifs buts maybes... it's not that I don't like the album, in the right context all the tracks are ok, great I'm not to sure...time will tell, I think once this 50th anniversary has come and gone and we are more settled, and can live with what we have......
|
|
|
Post by HOMETIME on May 26, 2023 17:28:36 GMT
I'm not going to be too popular with this opinion!! I don't think ABBA should appear at Eurovision next year, certainly not on stage, performing or speaking. We have to remember that this is not their night surely? If ABBA appear, that will be the only thing in the news, forget the winner!!?? There could be I suppose a small segment with maybe Bjorn saying good luck, but he did do that this year so why?? I agree. Imagine working day and night to perfect your Eurovision entry, only to be upstaged by ABBA with what would probably turn out, ultimately, to be some kind of ad for the Voyage shows? Yes, it'd be fantastic if we got some new music to celebrate the 50th anniversary, but there's no need to hitch it to the actual Eurovision. If Benny's grumpy dismissal of the mere notion of their appearance at Eurovision has achieved nothing else, it has at least make the conspiracy theorists look pretty silly. Maybe Agnetha and/or Frida will present Sweden's jury votes? That would be a pretty modest acknowledgement of the connection, without requiring too much of them. That BBC video was odd: Bjorn was most unBjorny, with his silences. Given the profile of the interviewer, something tells me it's part of something slightly bigger than simply getting the sullen "I don't want to and you can't make me do it!"
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 26, 2023 19:38:23 GMT
^ Imagine ALL of last year's entries being upstaged by Ukraine.
Eurovision Winners now are at best just one hit wonders and one week wonders at that.
Who knows perhaps next year's winner might be remembered for the act that won when ABBA were present.
I guess it would be unfair for ABBA to upstage whoever wins. At the same time I would like some kind of "thankyou, that's it and goodbye" next year.
I am not expecting or even want new music or thosr two unreleased songs.
|
|
|
Post by BAAB on May 26, 2023 20:15:08 GMT
I should imagine Benny is thinking "what more do people want?! We released a new album in late 2021 and an Avatar experience in 2022 for our actual 50th Anniversary, do we now have to do something for every bloody anniversary!? 50th year since this, that and the other"! Lol! Even if they did something else, people would still ask for more! They have gone out on a high, that hype generally won't be repeated. I wholeheartedly agreed!
|
|
|
Post by HOMETIME on May 26, 2023 20:34:19 GMT
^ Imagine ALL of last year's entries being upstaged by Ukraine. A result determined by an international public vote - this wouldn't be the case were ABBA to appear.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 26, 2023 20:44:24 GMT
^ True, an international public vote. But people not voting on the quality of the songs but sentiment (which was strong last year, less so this). For sure, ABBA would probably hijack next year's competion - as the Ukraine War did for last year's song fest
On the point of fans wanting "more" I agree with Benny in this clip
It really reminds me of the "ABBA owe us" brigade who demanded a new album or release of JLT.
Now we've had album and show some fans still want more. I don't think Benny helped matters wirh that lot by opening his gob about two unfinished tracks that were "quite good"
Yes, he certainly has a point about the More, More, More fans. Yet at the same time I can't feel he just likes stirring things up a bit with his revelations.
|
|
|
Post by evilincarnate on May 27, 2023 6:39:02 GMT
When you consider that work on 'Voyage' ceased in late August 2021 (as per Benny's comment regarding the final mix of "Keep An Eye On Dan"), it will soon be 2 years since any actual ABBA-related writing and recording was undertaken - to our knowledge.
There has been much fan speculation about the 2 unreleased 'Voyage' outtakes but we simply don't know whether they were not considered good enough for inclusion or if they were intentionally held back for future release. Benny did say in 2021 that these were both worthwhile songs but incomplete at that stage. I seem to recall him making similar comments about "I Still Have Faith In You" and "Don't Shut Me Down" soon after the April 2018 announcement - and that was 10 months after they had been recorded (in June 2017), let alone written. I think he reiterated this in late 2018/early 2019, referencing that orchestration was still required, along with some additional flourishes - i.e. this guy works at his own pace these days.
It should also not be forgotten that Bernard Löhr referred to several outtakes prior to the album's release in November 2021, which may indicate there were more than 2 unreleased songs. Perhaps there were additional 'lesser' songs that did not near completion but could be recycled at some stage?
For all we know, Benny may have been tinkering away during the last couple of years, with or without Bjorn/Bernard, so there could be compositions/recordings at various stages of completion. I often wonder if Bjorn wrote alongside Benny these days, whether he might encourage Benny to utilise more of his musical ideas that perhaps Benny simply discards? Benny has said in recent years that much of what he composes is unusable, retaining only a small percentage that he considers to be of any merit. I would be keen for these two to be in the same room, working as they did in the 1970's, sparring and pushing each other in a creative way - even if for just a few weeks here and there. I imagine much could be achieved if they would just focus on an album project with a particular timeframe in mind.
If an announcement or single release were to coincide with Eurovision 2024, a potential album release would not need to occur until November/December 2024, which effectively gives them 18 months to get their act together - that's if the impetus is there but who knows?
The reality is that they are all now nearing an age when this will not be possible for much longer. When the 4.5 year-gestation period of 'Voyage' is considered, there is an apparent degree of deterioration in the girls' vocals - just compare the chorus of "Don't Shut Me Down" with "When You Danced With Me". Whilst I'm fond of the latter, the vocals do sound a little shrill and definitely less fluid than those on the former. No bad thing, of course, but it's a reminder within the same body of work that time marches on.
Bjorn seems resigned to the idea that Benny carries the deciding vote no matter the venture, whilst Agnetha and Frida seem cautiously optimistic but unwilling to challenge Mr Grumpy. I wonder what would happen if the ladies actually made an appeal to Benny, referencing that time is finite and that they would like to have one last chapter together? Would they be dismissed outright or would he be true to his comment from late 2021 that he could have his arm twisted? Ludvig seems to have provided a potential clue with his recent comment about the possibility of another album, although he essentially retracted the comment on the spot. I don’t believe for a moment that this was a faux pas on his part but rather quite deliberate. One can only speculate at this stage but even that holds a certain fascination – and sense of hopefulness.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 27, 2023 7:24:59 GMT
Well written piece Evilincarnate
You are right to point to the deterioration of the girls' singing after those first two Voyage songs.
IMO those two Voyage songs were by far the best tracks - lyrically, nusically and vocally. There does seem to be an element of perfectionism in that it took them a long time from initial recording to final version.
I am not sure you can say that about the two unreleased songs given the downturn in quality after ISHFIY and DSMD
Getting back to the vocals for the Voyage set, best at the beginning 2017-18 rather than the end 2021. It is now 2023. Time is not on Agnetha or Frida's side. They are well into their 70s now and vocal ability will be a factor.
I don't think we'll see anything new. Those two unfinished songs may see the light of day in some form but I doubt with new vocals.
PS: I like references to Frida and Agnetha as "the girls" and Benny and Bjorn as "the boys". 😀
|
|
|
Post by BAAB on May 27, 2023 8:40:53 GMT
Benny is working on a new BAO Album. One never knows, if and what material he has in his brain or drawer which he might use for this album, maybe the "Recycling" already has begun...
Somehow I have a feeling that we will see something with the ABBAtares at the 2024 ESC
|
|
|
Post by HOMETIME on May 27, 2023 12:45:30 GMT
It should also not be forgotten that Bernard Löhr referred several outtakes prior to the album's release in November 2021, which may indicate there were more than 2 unreleased songs. Perhaps there were additional 'lesser' songs that did not near completion but could be recycled at some stage? Great post, Phil. It'd be interesting to hear more about the outtakes. In sessions for previous albums, recordings were sometimes scrapped and elements of the songs reworked into completely new compositions - the Dream World/Does Your Mother Know evolution jumps to mind as an example. I wonder if any of the finished tracks on Voyage started out as different songs? At times, it looks like Benny might take calls for more new music as an insult, rather than the tribute it really is. There are more gracious ways of saying no. The avuncular cuddlebunny schtick that formed his part of the ABBA PR back in the day seems to have given way to something grouchier. I agree that Ludvig's "faux pas" might well have been strategic. Personally, I'd like any new ABBA material not to have to try as hard to remind us who they are. With great songs and heartfelt performances, we really don't need every trademark bell and whistle in the mix.
|
|
|
Post by BAAB on May 27, 2023 15:39:56 GMT
The avuncular cuddlebunny schtick [/quote]
This is the first time in years I needed to google 3 English words in one sentence 😂 I hope to add them to my vocabulary 😁
Maybe it is the age... I mean, "Little Things" and "Bumblebee" for examples, would have suited much better on a BAO album but maybe Benny as a composer is not planning far in the future anymore, so if he has an idea and has a melody, hook, whatever... in mind, he will not keep it any longer in the drawer for future projects.
|
|
|
Post by BAAB on May 27, 2023 15:59:39 GMT
Btw.: Benny also said, that BAO will not tour anymore. They might still perform Here and there but no concerts and no tour anymore. His "No" to ESC doesn't seem to be ABBA or ESC specific but maybe more a general hint to retirement with nearly 80 years. Personaly, I love him for all the music he has brought to me in my life since I was a teen. Not only ABBA, but also Chess, Kristina Fran Duvemala, his Solo Stuff, all this with such high artistic quality. I do not expect or request anything from him. ABBA did not attend the 25th Waterloo Anniversary, the 30th Anniversary, the 40th Anniversary or the 45th Anniversary. So what ?
|
|
|
Post by Alan on May 27, 2023 20:45:19 GMT
Björn, Benny and Frida have attended the first anniversary night… no Agnetha. Disappointing, though Benny must be pleased as it takes the heat off him.
|
|
|
Post by Elaine on May 27, 2023 21:40:48 GMT
Whoever shot/posted this photograph in the Voyage Aniversary annual gig with the 3 Abba members attending the Audience just 'Thank you'!Btw Frida looks fine and as healthy as ever.Better than a year ago.
|
|
|
Post by janabbafan on May 27, 2023 21:47:03 GMT
Björn, Benny and Frida have attended the first anniversary night… no Agnetha. Disappointing, though Benny must be pleased as it takes the heat off him.
|
|
|
Post by janabbafan on May 27, 2023 21:48:56 GMT
"Benny must be pleased".... I think that remark is not correct.Not apropriate. Unless it was a joke.
|
|
|
Post by evilincarnate on May 28, 2023 3:06:13 GMT
"Benny must be pleased".... I think that remark is not correct.Not apropriate. Unless it was a joke. I'm pretty certain that the comment was referencing the fact that Benny was not facing the situation on his own as he was flanked by both Frida and Bjorn. I don't believe it was meant as a sleight against Agnetha - just re-read the comment in context.
|
|
|
Post by Alan on May 28, 2023 6:58:40 GMT
What I meant was that in the last few days, attention has been on Benny for apparently ruling out much happening next year. By Agnetha’s non-appearance last night, some attention falls on her as it could look like she might not be too fussed about doing much either.
Had it been just two of them last night, it wouldn’t have looked so bad, but as it was three, attention is going to fall on the one that was absent. OK, so they weren’t there to be interviewed and you could argue that their presence at the first anniversary night wasn’t too important, but it’s awkward seeing three of them. Sorry.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 28, 2023 9:03:05 GMT
I don't think Agnetha not appearing at the first anniversary of the Voyage show is a big deal. If she failed to turn up at the opening night then it would have been.
There's no reason for Benny to be diplomatic in his responses. As he rightly pointed out we got a new show and new album. Should he feel demands for more as a compliment? No not really. Maybe just accept the individual personalies and not "He should say this, or she should do that"
Having said that I would like *something* to mark the 50th Anniversary next year. Maybe just a statement saying "That's it. No more and thank you" a line needs to be drawn for recognising ABBA's achievements and the next stage of their individual lives.
I am not expecting any new music - or the release of the two unfinished songs at all.
|
|
|
Post by foreverfan on May 28, 2023 9:18:55 GMT
I was just thinking , and playing devils advocate....
" If one of us says NO" them that's all of us that say NO...no Agnetha........ emmmmmm
Now I'm only playing devils advocate, but Benny perhaps should be careful in what he says.... that said dammed if you do dammed if you don't...
But they have been in the " game " long enough now.......
|
|