|
Post by HOMETIME on May 12, 2022 14:30:33 GMT
I'm assuming they've already weighed these considerations up. If a new album somehow doesn't surface, will it be because of them? It would be sad if charts and sales were the only barometer of quality and satisfaction. They're old and wise enough - I hope! - to be confident that they have produced the goods, that they have fulfilled themselves. It's not like they're on skid row and need a commercial hit to survive.
|
|
|
Post by lamont on May 12, 2022 14:36:32 GMT
I like Little Things. It’s nice to have an Abba Christmas song to roll out every December. Agnetha & Frida’s vocals have a rawness about them in the song, not as polished as their other work. To have seen them singing around a piano, or in a dimly lit living room, with Twinkling lights and a log fire would have made it complete. The video doesn’t marry up with the song. It’s a melancholy little lullaby.
|
|
|
Post by welshboy on May 12, 2022 15:01:28 GMT
Well I played Voyage last night and I loved it all over again the 10 songs from start to finish the only down side is that it's to short. But I love all the songs I don't skip anything. Each song is wonderful in it's own way.
|
|
|
Post by HOMETIME on May 12, 2022 15:03:27 GMT
My thoughts too. What I particularly like about the Matt Pop remix is that it references ABBA's own history. It brings something else out of the tune. I think he did a particularly fine job with this track. It'd be nice if ABBA acknowledged it. I know they don't owe him anything and he did the remix without permission, but this particular mix could be helpful in rehabilitating a marmite song for the fans.
|
|
|
Post by gamleman on May 12, 2022 15:04:26 GMT
I saw a report today (Music Times) saying that the ABBA Voyage tickets are not selling well for the second tranche (Oct-Dec). This is something that could be verified by searching for tickets on Ticketmaster but I haven't done it. I expect there will a new surge of ticket sales once the publicity surrounding the launch gets underway but it does make you wonder whether there'll be a third phase of tickets. If they do go for a third quarter in London, this is motivation for ABBA to release new material in the Autumn to promote the early 2023 shows - perhaps that Voyage Deluxe edition with bonus tracks. I don't want to see a whole new album - I say ABBA have had a good and successful comeback, and let's leave it at that.
|
|
|
Post by clumsylikeaclown on May 12, 2022 15:38:47 GMT
Voyage itself has been a big success, but it's had an absurd knock-on effect for Gold as well. The last time it *wasn't* in the top 30 albums chart was April 2021, after the release of ISHFIY and DSMD it managed to peak at #5 and has danced around the top 20 for most of the time since.
I mentioned before that there isn't actually enough room to squeeze both songs onto the album as well for a re-release, so here's a question for you. If you were in charge of re-releasing ABBA Gold and were told you *had* to remove two tracks to replace with ISHFIY and DSMD, which two would you choose?
For me, I would probably (with a heavy heart) choose Thank You For The Music and Voulez-Vous.
|
|
|
Post by gamleman on May 12, 2022 16:34:39 GMT
OK, I just had a skim through the last couple of pages of that thread. What I saw was a lot of falling out and not really much talk about the topic. In my post above, I was more interested in the implications of poor ticket sales if they continue - what it might motivate them to do. Myself, I think the sales will recover over the Summer, assuming the show is initially well-received. I guess once it's established, it may be self-sustaining, as I think the Mamma Mia musical was. Otherwise, to maintain the momentum, they may need regular pushes of one sort or another, which could include further releases. Or they could move the show to another location.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 12, 2022 16:37:57 GMT
I would chose Does Your Mother Know and I Have a Dream.
I have raised this issue too.
You could include DSMD if you 1. Revert to the original edits of VV and TNOTG 2. Edit out the bridge section of GGG
I wouldn't mind one or both of those Voyage tracks being on Gold but clearly not everyone agrees.😀
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 12, 2022 16:52:16 GMT
Yes 😀
Gamleman is right. Ticket sales are low for Oct to Dec. And no he's isn't being negative to raise this 😀.
Ticket sales seem to mirror the Voyage album's sales. Huge initial demand first week, respectable for a few more weeks then a big drop off.
Personally, I would be disappointed if they didn't pick up.
It's not a given they will. ABBA will have to promote the show. I sure they will and this will help to some extent.
It seems to me 3 issues.
1. People don't know what to expect. If it was ABBA, I am 100% convinced massive sellout.
2. Pricing. If you look there are some reasonably priced tickets in the autumn but you really have to search. Lots of expensive hotel packages and private booth tickets.
3. Location. As I said on that other post, location not ideal but realistic. The nature of the event means it had to be in specially made venue - so away from the West End and more casual tourist/theatre goers.
Let's hope too there's no technical hiccups and the show gets great reviews.
As for a new album, I am pretty happy we got Voyage. ABBA don't owe us anymore - and that includes deluxe set or releasing those two unfinished songs.
Possibly ABBA and their advisors got too carried away with Gold and the Mamma Mia films. These appeal to casual ABBA fans.
The 'real' ABBA fans are the ones who bought the Voyage album. Ticket sales are in that league ...so far.
The show could be promoted more as a Greatest Hits show to attract the more numerous casual fans. Someone here raised that - either Bennybjorn or Gamleman, I think.
Other opinions are available. 😘
|
|
|
Post by gamleman on May 12, 2022 17:27:18 GMT
A dip in ticket sales during the quiet period (ABBA-wise) since Christmas is pretty understandable, especially when the show hasn't started yet. The show launch will no doubt boost ticket sales and over the Summer people will start to think about treats for the Autumn and the run-up to Christmas (cost of living crisis permitting). A third quarter (Jan-March) is a more of an unknown though.
The article that I read suggested that the venue not being close to the restaurants of central London may be a problem, but I can't see that. What proportion of this audience will be wanting a restaurant meal before the show?
I mentioned that ABBA Voyage was an ill-judged name for both the album and show, when they do not correspond to each other. I don't think it was me who suggested that a "Greatest Hits" type branding for the show would have been more appropriate and more enticing to casual ABBA fans, but it is a very good point. Even something like "Voyage: The First 50 Years" (tongue-in-cheek title) would have been more informative.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 12, 2022 17:50:26 GMT
Going beyond this year, then the Voyage concert would need general tourists who want to see a "show". More likely they'll go to the West End than the Olympic Park.
Prices have to be competitive too.
|
|
|
Post by Michal on May 12, 2022 19:17:28 GMT
I mentioned before that there isn't actually enough room to squeeze both songs onto the album as well for a re-release, so here's a question for you. If you were in charge of re-releasing ABBA Gold and were told you *had* to remove two tracks to replace with ISHFIY and DSMD, which two would you choose? I Have A Dream and Thank You For The Music. The first because it's never been among my favourites (but as a UK No.2 single it's removal doesn't make sense) and the second because it's not really one of their biggest hits.
|
|
|
Post by Michal on May 12, 2022 19:27:48 GMT
It seems to me 3 issues. 1. People don't know what to expect. If it was ABBA, I am 100% convinced massive sellout. 2. Pricing. If you look there are some reasonably priced tickets in the autumn but you really have to search. Lots of expensive hotel packages and private booth tickets. 3. Location. As I said on that other post, location not ideal but realistic. The nature of the event means it had to be in specially made venue - so away from the West End and more casual tourist/theatre goers. I'd say the first two are the main issues. Even being a huge ABBA fan, I didn't mean to see it before some reviews keep coming. And the casual fans are even less likely to pay so much if they don't know what to expect. I guess that if the show is a success (and I really believe it will be), it will attract much more "ordinary" people, who will go not only to hear the ABBA songs but also to see the technology.
|
|
|
Post by Michal on May 12, 2022 19:39:57 GMT
I'm not too worried about the failure of a follow-up album (if there is any). As HOMETIME pointed out, they don't need to prove themselves anymore. Somebody here called the Voyage album an "anomaly" and a "zombie album". A tenth studio album released for the 50th anniversary would actually make Voyage less "unbelievable" and I would probably finally realize it wasn't just a dream and they really returned But of course I'm immensely grateful for Voyage and agree ABBA already gave us more than we ever dreamt of and owe us nothing.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 13, 2022 5:59:02 GMT
Bow out on a high with Voyage.
I don't want a repeat of The Visitors album being followed by 6 songs that varied from just okay to meh. And the huge commercial failure too.
Disagreeing with Hometime. It would be horrible if ABBA released something substandard. Go out on a high.
Let's all be grateful for the Voyage album and hope the show is a success.
|
|
|
Post by HOMETIME on May 13, 2022 7:16:25 GMT
Disagreeing with Hometime. It would be horrible if ABBA released something substandard. Go out on a high. I never suggested that ABBA would or should release anything substandard. What I said was that no matter how great another album might be, the newsworthiness/chart performance might not match that achieved by Voyage. It's possible to go out on a creative high.
|
|
|
Post by gamleman on May 13, 2022 8:23:15 GMT
If ABBA want to finish on a high album-wise, they should not release another studio album - it could be a great success, but there is the risk of it being an anti-climax. If it didn't make No 1, I'm sure the press and perhaps the public would deem it a failure, here in the UK anyway. Both ABBA and the hardcore fans may see it differently, although I think B&B are conscious of success. Personally, I see "Voyage" as closure, not the start of a second phase of ABBA's career. I wouldn't object to further individual tracks released on a retrospective compilation as long as the quality is there - so I would like tracks of the quality of TDBYC and JLT and even Cassandra, not YOMO and IATC. I'll leave UA as somewhere in the middle
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 13, 2022 8:53:27 GMT
Disagreeing with Hometime. It would be horrible if ABBA released something substandard. Go out on a high. I never suggested that ABBA would or should release anything substandard. What I said was that no matter how great another album might be, the newsworthiness/chart performance might not match that achieved by Voyage. It's possible to go out on a creative high. Fair enough. Personally, I am happy with Voyage being the last ever ABBA album and I think it will be. It would be sad if a new album wasn't that good - or was a flop. Sales might not matter to artists that haven't had much sucess but not for ABBA. That blocking facility clearly not working 😀
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 13, 2022 8:54:47 GMT
If ABBA want to finish on a high album-wise, they should not release another studio album - it could be a great success, but there is the risk of it being an anti-climax. If it didn't make No 1, I'm sure the press and perhaps the public would deem it a failure, here in the UK anyway. Both ABBA and the hardcore fans may see it differently, although I think B&B are conscious of success. Personally, I see "Voyage" as closure, not the start of a second phase of ABBA's career. I wouldn't object to further individual tracks released on a retrospective compilation as long as the quality is there - so I would like tracks of the quality of TDBYC and JLT and even Cassandra, not YOMO and IATC. I'll leave UA as somewhere in the middle Agreed! I think some fans want new songs whatever the quality.
|
|
|
Post by justabba on May 13, 2022 10:08:41 GMT
Why would ABBA suddenly release substandard material? That's rather disingenuous.
|
|
|
Post by foreverfan on May 13, 2022 10:13:02 GMT
Of course, I’d love to hear more, I shouldn’t think many if any wouldn’t. I know the subject has been touched on before, but alas they can’t go on and on and on to use a pun..It’s good to bow out at the top, and we’ve been lucky to see that. So alas I do think this is the last studio album, I feel we might just get a couple more tracks that will inevitably end up on some compilation . I feel that this is probably it, and in a funny way resigned myself to it. whether the “Show” will throw up a few releases who knows, but somehow doubt it.
I’ve calmed down on my listens to ABBA recently, Voyage overkill..lol so need to get back in touch with the oldies and gradually mingle both ...
We are in for a few weeks more of hype from media, whether it’s good or bad and no doubt those TV old and new programmes will be shown again, we may see Voyage back in the UK charts and Gold rising yet again, so I tend to enjoy it while it lasts, as it’s going to fade a lot quicker than we think, especially if nothing new !!
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 13, 2022 10:54:35 GMT
Why would ABBA suddenly release substandard material? That's rather disingenuous. I take it this is a reference to my post. For future reference please refer to me if talking about any comments I may make and don't just single me out if others make similar points. 😀 Both myself and Gamleman (and others in this Forum such as Eddie and Foreverfan) have said we don't want (or expect) any new album. We're happy that Voyage is the end. As for new realeases it is perfectly reasonable to want them to be of a good quality (and to do well). I am not saying there will be a whole album of substandard material - as I don't believe there will be a new album. The two unfinished songs *might* be substandard, if so I'd rather they were not released. But they *might* be very good, in which case, fine. Yes B+B have a quality threshold but sometimes it doesn't work. From The Visitors, Two for the Price of One From 1982, You Owe Me One, Under Attack or I am the City. From Voyage, Little Things. Summing up. I am happy ABBA gave us a new album. I am not expecting more. If an odd track is released as a single or bonus track, I just want it to be good. PS. I wish Benny didn't say there were two unfinished songs. He knows how many fans were about Just Like That. He should have said nothing - so no speculation, or a nice surprise if they are good.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 13, 2022 11:06:48 GMT
We are in for a few weeks more of hype from media, whether it’s good or bad and no doubt those TV old and new programmes will be shown again, we may see Voyage back in the UK charts and Gold rising yet again, so I tend to enjoy it while it lasts, as it’s going to fade a lot quicker than we think, especially if nothing new !! I agree with this.
|
|
|
Post by gamleman on May 13, 2022 11:40:24 GMT
Johnny, I actually like "Two For The Price Of One" - I think its quirky chorus with the girls' backing vocals is wonderful and it's a song (along with HOH) that lightens up an otherwise very dark album (although I do like the dark parts).
I agree that sometimes (rarely?) B&B make mistakes regarding which songs to release and I think we have been through mistakes made in choices of singles. And even for album tracks and B-sides, we know that great songs (e.g. DW and JLT) have been overlooked in favour of lesser songs. I wouldn't put LT right at the bottom of the barrel but I think it was a mistake to include a Christmas song on the "Voyage" album - it would have been fine as a B-side / bonus track on a Christmas single, such as WYDWM.
I fully expect a Voyage deluxe edition in time for Christmas, which will probably include a couple of new tracks, although I would prefer to seem them on a retrospective album. I see "Voyage" as complete, majestically rounded off with OTF and I wouldn't want them to add bonus tracks after OTF - I'd prefer them to find some way of integrating the new songs into the rest of the album. I wouldn't object to them replacing LT with another track, although I'm pretty sure they won't do that.
|
|
|
Post by richard on May 13, 2022 11:56:07 GMT
What does going out on an high mean? And whose high? And in whose opinion? It's music! That's why I occasionally get irritated when someone expresses their negative opinion about a piece of music as if it was objective fact. Yes, qualifying all the time what one says about songs with an "in my opinion" is unnecessary, but sometimes it's appropriate if sensitivity to context matters.
I'm still amazed, happy, and grateful that the Voyage album has appeared, even if my appreciation for some the songs, after my initial enthusiasm, has declined somewhat; and maybe I'd feel the same about a 50th Anniversary album. But I'd still love to see it appear and to hear it.
I assume musicians, generally, want to make music, provided they still feel capable of doing so. The assumption that ABBA might now be past it and it's probably best that they record no more, I find very negative, to say the least And maybe, artistically, a 50th Anniversary album could turn out to be better than Voyage - imo, of course. 😄
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 13, 2022 12:05:01 GMT
Gamleman, the demo version of Two for the Price of One is better.
"I have no romance in my life Sometimes I wish I had a knife" and cleaning the toilets not the platforms.
I think WYDWM musically sounds quite Christmassy. If only they had chosen that for Christmas lyrics. Yep, as a Christmas song Little Things doesn't fit on Voyage.
I can't see it being replaced on Voyage.
Ode to Freedom seems like a natural ending on Voyage - just Like An Angel Passing Through My Room was on The Visitors. But that didn't stop bonus songs after it.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 13, 2022 12:09:49 GMT
Richard, like Hometime you use the word "negative" to describe somebody with a different view. It's not helpful or constructive. It is denigrating. I stopped posting in the Concert thread for the adverse comments I got only to find them in here now. Yes, I like disagreements and have some with members on here but some are just nasty. I really wish there was a block button but there isn't - despite what Hometime says.
I won't post more. It's not fun.
|
|
|
Post by richard on May 13, 2022 12:27:50 GMT
I've got lots of negative views about things, including music. My post was more considered than that - if I say so myself. And I don't want to block anyone.
|
|
|
Post by HOMETIME on May 13, 2022 12:55:45 GMT
I really wish there was a block button but there isn't - despite what Hometime says. Hope this helps. 1. Click on the name of the member you wish to block. 2. On the right of your screen, you'll see a little down arrow. Click this and you'll have the option to block the member or give them a gift. 3. Repeat as often as necessary. 4. When you're logged in, you'll see posts from blocked members as follows - you have the choice to look behind the block or move on.
|
|
|
Post by gamleman on May 13, 2022 13:03:15 GMT
Myself, I don't think the demo version of TFTPOO is better - I assume you meant lyric-wise, Johnny. I'm not sure I like the idea of an ABBA lyric featuring the word toilets And the word knife brings us back to a dark theme. Indeed, bonus tracks were added to the end of "The Visitors" but this was many years after its initial release. All this talk of negativity and positivity seems very modern and analytical. Surely, this forum is here to share opinions, positive or negative, good or bad - that is, to allow us to express ourselves about ABBA and related topics. We don't need to become offended when someone disagrees with us. We can politely disagree.
|
|