|
Post by clumsylikeaclown on May 4, 2022 10:09:57 GMT
Every Gold track is excellent to me, but if I *had* to choose a 'least favourite' of the lot... probably Thank You For The Music. Had it been my own choice I'd have replaced that one with I Do x 5. Much as I love The Day Before You Came, there's one part of the lyrics I never quite wrapped my head around. The beginning makes clear that it takes her around 1 hour 15 minutes from leaving her house to being at her desk (leaves at 8, gets there 9:15). And she leaves at 5pm and gets the train back home, which you'd assume would take a similar amount of time. But it then jumps to 'I must have opened my front door at 8 o'clock or so'... which leaves nearly two hours unaccounted for. Even factoring in that she stopped on the way back for some Chinese takeaway (apparently Agnetha herself liked Chinese food a lot), I don't see how this would take up so much time. Was there a major train delay or other issue that delayed her commute home by an hour? Did she run an errand or two before getting dinner? Everything else about this song is so detailed the fact that there's this gap bugs me. And yes, before you ask I have spent far too long thinking about this... Yes, this difference in travel times puzzled me from the outset. I think she should have looked for another job if it was taking her three hours to get home. I guess it's to do with the lyrics fitting - seven wouldn't have worked and six was too soon after leaving work. I learnt the phrase 'food to go' from this song - I had never heard it before, as we would say 'takeaway'. The 'it fits the melody' explanation is the obvious answer - the closest to a time that fits the melody and makes sense given the time scales stated is 'half past six'. Theoretically possible if the takeaway served her very quickly! I'm just gonna assume there was a major train delay that day AND the takeaway was super busy so the two things combined made her late. Onto a less asinine topic, Frida's operatic line is the perfect example of 'quality over quantity'. She can command a whole lot of presence even when she's not singing any actual words...
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 4, 2022 10:22:14 GMT
TDBYC is in my rotating Top 3 ABBA songs with The Visitors and LAAPTMR - they all get a go in the No.1 position depending on my mood. TNOTG is a big favourite with me too - so slinky and elegant. I like LAAPTMR and TNOTG but I don't think either would be suitable for the Voyage concert and neither will be featured.The best part of TDBYC for me is the ending. The Visitors is a great, dramatic song. It will be at the show and I guess the first time hearing it for Gold/Mamma Mia fans.
|
|
|
Post by gamleman on May 4, 2022 10:59:22 GMT
Ooh, harsh words about TDBYC Johnny I agree that LAAPTMR is not suitable for the show and maybe even TNOTG. I think the big ABBA ballads that needed a lot of studio trickery in their production are best left out of a live show, and I would include KMKY in that. On the other hand, there is no real need to use the live vocals in this show, since it is essentially mimed - they could use the studio vocals. I hope for "The Visitors" track they have a projected backdrop with books, paintings and furniture to portray the story, as otherwise it will fall flat.
|
|
|
Post by HOMETIME on May 4, 2022 14:15:09 GMT
I hope for "The Visitors" track they have a projected backdrop with books, paintings and furniture to portray the story, as otherwise it will fall flat. Given that the song is about an oppressive Russian regime and given that Bjorn gave an impassioned speech in which he called Putin an asshole on a TV show in support of Ukraine, and Benny led a choir with a lovely version of ABBA's Ode To Freedom, it might not be out of the realms of possibility that any associated imagery might underscore the lyrics more pointedly...? I understand that TDBYC is a bit of a marmite song. I love that ABBA had progressed that far by then (even if they seemed stuck in a bit of denial with songs like UA, IATC and YOMO at the time). I think it's a song that would have worked well on Voyage, had it not been previously released. I agree, though, that ballads and mid-tempo songs have to be used carefully and sparingly in a show like this. Years ago, I had this hope that ABBA would regroup for an age-appropriate acoustic/orchestral TV special. Specially invited audience, a tasteful setlist that gave some focus to these more mature and introspective songs. I saw it as a goodbye and a celebration of work beyond the shimmer and bling. But we have a whole new album and a live experience nobody expected, so my little dream was far exceeded!
|
|
|
Post by clumsylikeaclown on May 4, 2022 15:02:09 GMT
I hope for "The Visitors" track they have a projected backdrop with books, paintings and furniture to portray the story, as otherwise it will fall flat. Given that the song is about an oppressive Russian regime and given that Bjorn gave an impassioned speech in which he called Putin an asshole on a TV show in support of Ukraine, and Benny led a choir with a lovely version of ABBA's Ode To Freedom, it might not be out of the realms of possibility that any associated imagery might underscore the lyrics more pointedly...? I understand that TDBYC is a bit of a marmite song. I love that ABBA had progressed that far by then (even if they seemed stuck in a bit of denial with songs like UA, IATC and YOMO at the time). I think it's a song that would have worked well on Voyage, had it not been previously released. I agree, though, that ballads and mid-tempo songs have to be used carefully and sparingly in a show like this. Years ago, I had this hope that ABBA would regroup for an age-appropriate acoustic/orchestral TV special. Specially invited audience, a tasteful setlist that gave some focus to these more mature and introspective songs. I saw it as a goodbye and a celebration of work beyond the shimmer and bling. But we have a whole new album and a live experience nobody expected, so my little dream was far exceeded! Thematically, that would be amazing. But given how long these things take I'm not sure if that would possibly be too complex to change so late in the game? Interesting what you said about the 1982 songs though - they do show evidence of an 'identity crisis' of sorts. That's not to knock any of the songs, mind- unlike many I love You Owe Me One, though for years I assumed it was only Frida on lead and not both of them!
|
|
|
Post by gamleman on May 4, 2022 15:20:42 GMT
I suspect that UA, YOMO and IATC sounded like they did because ABBA were trying to sound modern, adopting the technology of the time. Do we think that B&B were trying some sort of voice processing technology to try to achieve the layered ABBA harmonies in a more efficient way? I don't know enough about recording technology to be certain, but something was going on. However, I find these songs melodically simpler too and a bit of a backward step. Around that time (1982), Bucks Fizz were having a good deal of success with a basic Pop sound - could ABBA have been attempting to return to this kind sound after the sophistication of "The Visitors" (album)?
|
|
|
Post by AdamDawson2003 on May 4, 2022 15:31:12 GMT
40 years ago today on 4th May 1982 ABBA recorded 'Just Like That'.
|
|
|
Post by HOMETIME on May 4, 2022 16:15:24 GMT
... unlike many I love You Owe Me One, though for years I assumed it was only Frida on lead and not both of them! I have a fondness for its daft charm too - and I also thought it was a Frida lead. She must be a bit more forward in the mix. And gamleman, Bucks Fizz's 1982 album is far from basic. They took a giant leap up the evolutionary ladder with the Are You Ready album. Two number one singles, a further Top 10 entry and at least four other potential singles on the disc. I know it's almost verboten to praise them, but they really delivered the goods that year. I know that Bjorn referenced The Buggles Video Killed The Radio Star in relation to Under Attack, but it was a three-year old hit by then. Trevor Horn of The Buggles is an amazing pop producer. He had delivered a lot of inspiring productions by then, including ABC's Lexicon of Love and Dollar's four best singles ( Hand held in black and white; Mirror mirror, Give me back my heart; Videotheque). Any/all of these could have been great production references/inspirations and more in keeping with the times. 1981-1984 was a fantastic period for shiny pop. ABBA might have outgrown some of that by '81/'82, but they still had it in them to deliver absolute brilliance. They might have been just a little too timid with some of their singles choices. Sorry, I'm at risk of going wildly off topic.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 4, 2022 16:27:36 GMT
Adam, I love " Just Like That ". It has such a haunting melody and very plaintive vocals from Agnetha. Shame the song will never see the light of day as Benny and Bjorn are resolutely adamant releasing it although both Frida and Agnetha think otherwise. Tony, a shocking confession, both Dollar and Five Star were both my favourite acts from the eighties. ABBA excepted of course ! Not forgetting Nik Kershaw, Laura Branigan and The Pointer Sisters. How sad is that !
|
|
|
Post by HOMETIME on May 4, 2022 16:51:40 GMT
Tony, a shocking confession, both Dollar and Five Star were both my favourite acts from the eighties. ABBA excepted of course ! Not forgetting Nik Kershaw, Laura Branigan and The Pointer Sisters. How sad is that ! Oooh, Eddie, that's neither shocking nor sad. I have no time for the concept of "guilty pleasures" - what ever way music works for you is perfect. Dollar had some great singles aside from the four Horn-produced gems. My biggest problem with Dollar is David Van Day - he's an absolute knob. I love the Pointer Sisters too - Back In My Arms is a fantastic song.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 4, 2022 17:17:20 GMT
Tony, I totally agree you with about David Van Day. The Pointer Sisters did record some great songs. Also, I thought " Wouldn't It Be Good " by Nik Kershaw was a brilliant song. Oh dear I am veering from the " Voyage " discussion !
|
|
|
Post by gamleman on May 4, 2022 17:26:26 GMT
And gamleman , Bucks Fizz's 1982 album is far from basic. They took a giant leap up the evolutionary ladder with the Are You Ready album. Two number one singles, a further Top 10 entry and at least four other potential singles on the disc. I know it's almost verboten to praise them, but they really delivered the goods that year. I know that Bjorn referenced The Buggles Video Killed The Radio Star in relation to Under Attack, but it was a three-year old hit by then. Trevor Horn of The Buggles is an amazing pop producer. He had delivered a lot of inspiring productions by then, including ABC's Lexicon of Love and Dollar's four best singles ( Hand held in black and white; Mirror mirror, Give me back my heart; Videotheque). Any/all of these could have been great production references/inspirations and more in keeping with the times. 1981-1984 was a fantastic period for shiny pop. ABBA might have outgrown some of that by '81/'82, but they still had it in them to deliver absolute brilliance. They might have been just a little too timid with some of their singles choices. Sorry, I'm at risk of going wildly off topic. Yes, 'basic' was the wrong word re Bucks Fizz when I meant mainstream Pop or something similar - the musical equivalent of good English cooking (although I can hear the objections to that coming already). Certainly, "My Camera Never Lies" wasn't basic - it's a song that I can imagine ABBA performing and it is perhaps the most ABBA-inspired song from Bucks Fizz. And "Now Those Days Are Gone" was sheer class. I liked the "Are You Ready" album (I have two vinyl copies) but wouldn't say that it's a classic album in the way I regard many ABBA albums. Oh dear, this post is going to get moved for talking too much about Bucks Fizz, so I'd better say a bit more about ABBA. Basically at that point, they didn't look happy - the cover of the "Under Attack" single on which they looked like washed-out zombies said it all.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 4, 2022 18:05:10 GMT
Gamleman, I agree with you that we are steering away from the main discussion topic. Let's get back to " Voyage ". I wonder if any other forum members will be compiling their " Voyage " dream concert set song list. We have very interesting song choice lists already posted.
|
|
|
Post by Alan on May 4, 2022 22:16:14 GMT
How time flies. Six months ago today we were gearing up to hear Voyage for the first time (and some of us had already done so). It was like Christmas Eve as a child. I look back at the time fondly. That whole two-month build-up was a great time. The Voyage show seemed such a long way off at that point but now we’re into the last few weeks of anticipation. Not the same as waiting for the album, but exciting nonetheless.
|
|
|
Post by Alan on May 5, 2022 11:57:48 GMT
No one’s in touch with foreverfan (Graham) are they? He hasn’t posted for a week, and I made those structural changes to the forum since then. He was online early on 2 May though, which was after the main changes were completed. Hope we haven’t lost him - I did wonder if some might not be able to find this topic but most have. Colin onlyabba4meagain too. Any others missing in action?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 5, 2022 12:01:20 GMT
Alan, it does indeed. I can recall the announcement of ABBA's comeback, new album and a forthcoming ABBAtars concert. I can still feel that suspense and sheer buzz of joy and excitement. I never thought ABBA would reform let alone a brand new studio album. I hope there is a special programme about the return of ABBA. the making of the album " Voyage " and the forthcoming concert. Maybe I am asking way too much. No, I haven't read any recent posts from Graham. I hope he is OK.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 5, 2022 12:11:09 GMT
Alan, Colin occasionally posts on the forum but not recently and I haven't seen any threads from Rubberball Man for a very long time. I hope they are both OK.
|
|
|
Post by Alan on May 5, 2022 12:17:19 GMT
Thanks @eddie. Yes, I was wondering about The Rubber Ball Man as well. He’s been gone a while. Not posted since 12 November and not online since beginning of April.
|
|
|
Post by foreverfan on May 5, 2022 12:32:34 GMT
Hi.. I’m still alive and kicking..lol Alan please don’t think I’d mind on you moving a post, as said Eurovision is not everyone’s cup of tea, and I’m big enough to understand that not all subjects are of an interest. I find myself in a strange predicament, as I usually don’t mind speculating on various out comes, ie, set list, but at the moment...no... The usuals will be there, just hope for something more unusual , like The Visitors... I’m looking forward to the show, on the 30th, a little apprehensive, as quite a lot of negativity going around, not just on here but in general, I guess I’ll make up my own mind soon enough, but hey let’s give it a chance, is it a British thing, to trash before it’s begun.....
|
|
|
Post by Alan on May 5, 2022 12:35:21 GMT
Ah, good to see you back, foreverfan. I was wondering if you had the URL for this topic saved, and it now wouldn’t work after I’d changed things round. Was having visions of you not being able to find the forum! I emailed The Rubber Ball Man and he very quickly responded - he’s been busy with university and essays (far more important than a forum) but hopes to be back on here soon as he’s nearly finished.
|
|
|
Post by AdamDawson2003 on May 5, 2022 18:02:43 GMT
40 years ago today on 5th May 1982 ABBA recorded 'I Am The City'.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 5, 2022 18:03:17 GMT
You're very welcome, Alan. I'm glad we sort of rounded up the troops. Glad to hear all concerned are well. I hope you enjoy the concert, Graham.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 5, 2022 18:05:08 GMT
Adam, I do like " I Am The City ". Quite a quirky pop song with great vocals from both Frida and Agnetha.
|
|
|
Post by AdamDawson2003 on May 5, 2022 19:28:29 GMT
Adam, I do like " I Am The City ". Quite a quirky pop song with great vocals from both Frida and Agnetha. 'I Am The City' should have been released as a single in 1982 it could have done well had ABBA given it a chance and even though 'Just Like That' is a wonderful song and way better than any B-Side song it would be the only song they had remaining from the 1982 sessions to put on the B-Side.
|
|
|
Post by madonnabba on May 6, 2022 5:57:08 GMT
The problem with JLT was those awkward lyrics. Under Attack had better lyrics but I was not keen on the sound of the song. Seemed dated by 1982.
|
|
|
Post by undertheappletree on May 6, 2022 6:10:30 GMT
Back in 82, l don't think either JLT or l am the City' would of made more than a ripple in the Charts, their popularity had definitely faded, a long with their public appearances. Fast forward to 85, if they had recorded the Chess Songs has Abba Songs, 'One Night in Bangkok' which was an mega hit Single Worldwide, and 'l Know him so well' which was a mega selling Single in the UK, out selling Dancing Queen, Abba's best Seller.
All Speculation once again...
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 6, 2022 7:43:44 GMT
" Just Like That " is indeed a great song and better than " I Am The City ". Unfortunately Benny and Bjorn are not happy with it as they have concluded that the track is actually two different songs which don't work together. I don't agree. However I " rest my case ". I am not going to argue with them.
|
|
|
Post by gamleman on May 6, 2022 7:55:46 GMT
I think JLT is one of those hypnotic, radio-friendly songs that would have been a huge hit in 1982 or 1983 irrespective of the fading public interest in ABBA - it may have given them a new lease of life. The lyrics are not awkward - part of the reason the chorus works so well is that the lyrics fit in so well with the snappy melody. I wouldn't have dreamt of putting IATC on an A-side and JLT on the B-side, as someone suggested - that would have been totally wrong.
I can't imagine ABBA singing "One Night In Bangkok", apart from providing backing vocals, but IKHSW, NS and HHMH, yes.
|
|
|
Post by undertheappletree on May 6, 2022 8:47:23 GMT
I have always preferred Gemini's finished version of JLT over ABBA's demo Snippets, also the Title just reminds me of Tommy Cooper's comic one liner, and some of the lyrics, like smug has a Cat, l always tend to say snug has a rug, maybe that's part of the beauty of ABBA, some of the daft and over emphasised lyrics.
B&B must have had faith in the Gemini Version, they did promote it back then appearing on Wogan Show for one, performing it with Gemini'
Who knows they may have re worked it for the Voyage Show, seeing JAN got released, as a fan favourite, Maybe the Girls twisted the guys arms.
|
|
|
Post by gamleman on May 6, 2022 9:34:52 GMT
Of course, when you hear the phrase "Just Like That", you think of Tommy Cooper, although nowadays I think of the ABBA song first. I imagine that "smug as a cat" is a Bjorn invention - the other expression is "snug as a bug in a rug", which is quite different. I didn't realise that Gemini had performed JLT on Terry Wogan's show. Somehow, the Gemini version passed me by - although I was aware of the unfinished ABBA song, I didn't hear or buy the Gemini version until the late 90s. I'm not sure that Gemini were right for the international market in the early 80s. After ABBA, I thought B&B would put their production efforts into more current music and by well-known artists.
|
|