|
Post by madonnabba on May 6, 2022 10:10:26 GMT
Just my opinion. Not keen on those lyrics...meandering rivers and throwing dust in my eyes. Tune good though. Not keen on the lyrics for DDD but that was years before. Don't think YOMO would have made it to album track had there been another album around that time.
|
|
|
Post by clumsylikeaclown on May 6, 2022 10:47:03 GMT
Of course, when you hear the phrase "Just Like That", you think of Tommy Cooper, although nowadays I think of the ABBA song first. I imagine that "smug as a cat" is a Bjorn invention - the other expression is "snug as a bug in a rug", which is quite different. I didn't realise that Gemini had performed JLT on Terry Wogan's show. Somehow, the Gemini version passed me by - although I was aware of the unfinished ABBA song, I didn't hear or buy the Gemini version until the late 90s. I'm not sure that Gemini were right for the international market in the early 80s. After ABBA, I thought B&B would put their production efforts into more current music and by well-known artists. The 'smug as a cat' line is interesting, because 'the cat that got the cream' is a common expression that means exactly the same thing and there are other similar idioms out there but the exact phrase 'smug as a cat'... not so much. Sadly I can't see any of their 1982 songs as being capable of being big hits back then. To this day I wonder what could've been of When All Is Said And Done had been the 2nd single from the Visitors and not Head Over Heels - I'd like to think it would've at least been a top 10 hit.
|
|
|
Post by richard on May 6, 2022 10:49:42 GMT
Maybe this avatar show would never have been an idea, let alone got off the ground, had ABBA continued as an intermittent group from about the time when the Gold compilation first appeared. But perhaps Benny's awkward attitude towards Frida then, and for quite a while afterwards, put paid to any possibility of that? (Apologies if I've said something inappropriate, but there might be something in it?) We could have had several additional albums by now; and I'm sure a lot of fans could regard it as 'what might have been'.
Regarding singers being able to sing to a worthwhile or good quality into an older age, I remember hearing a live Neil Sedaka concert on BBC Radio 2 a few years and he sounded fantastic, imo, in his 70s.
Just Like That keeps getting mentioned by some of us not because we have thought too highly of it because it was never officially released, but because, unlike Benny and Björn, we actually rate it. I now think the problem is the sub-standard instrumentation and the arrangement of the verses. The lyrics don't bother me, usually - and I suspect this is the case for a lot of pop music lovers - if I like the music side of things. If Just A Notion, then why not Just Like That? Well, obviously Benny and Björn think JAN is a better song - and that's the end of it.
|
|
|
Post by lamont on May 6, 2022 13:04:05 GMT
Maybe this avatar show would never have been an idea, let alone got off the ground, had ABBA continued as an intermittent group from about the time when the Gold compilation first appeared. But perhaps Benny's awkward attitude towards Frida then, and for quite a while afterwards, put paid to any possibility of that? (Apologies if I've said something inappropriate, but there might be something in it?) We could have had several additional albums by now; and I'm sure a lot of fans could regard it as 'what might have been'. Regarding singers being able to sing to a worthwhile or good quality into an older age, I remember hearing a live Neil Sedaka concert on BBC Radio 2 a few years and he sounded fantastic, imo, in his 70s. Just Like That keeps getting mentioned by some of us not because we have thought too highly of it because it was never officially released, but because, unlike Benny and Björn, we actually rate it. I now think the problem is the sub-standard instrumentation and the arrangement of the verses. The lyrics don't bother me, usually - and I suspect this is the case for a lot of pop music lovers - if I like the music side of things. If Just A Notion, then why not Just Like That? Well, obviously Benny and Björn think JAN is a better song - and that's the end of it. I agree somewhat about Benny, but I think it was the whole ‘ABBA’ idea in itself, perhaps it became too big and Benny was always more interested in the music. In the old ABBA fanzine ‘Express’ in the eighties they examined quotes from the ABBA members regarding a reunion, despite many thinking it was Agnetha who was resistant, if looked more like Benny. Agnetha I think was a bit more diplomatic and ambiguous in her answers! Later on, in The Winner Takes It All documentary Benny again noted it was no big deal about the divorces, and couldn’t understand ABBA‘a appeal to the LGBTQ+ community with the “do they think we look like transvestites?” Line. Yes, Benny looked uncomfortable with Frida at times, even up to 2004 backstage footage from Mamma Mia anniversary in London. I’m only speculating and my opinions are subjective but Benny admitted himself to having an alcohol problem and sought help, I wonder if this started Benny‘a acceptance of his past with his private & professional life, which started the organic process of Voyage… Just my thoughts, if I am out of line I apologise.
|
|
|
Post by tagaytay on May 6, 2022 13:19:36 GMT
i think i also have read some interviews wherein Benny would dismiss ABBA as music they did a long time ago (and this was in the 90s i think when they were active in Chess and Kristina). And I remember Frida also in the 90s advising fans to move on from ABBA since they were not ABBA anymore.
|
|
|
Post by gamleman on May 6, 2022 13:37:18 GMT
As I alluded to earlier, I think it is a shame that B&B didn't make more of their songwriting and production services in the post-ABBA years. Apart from ABBA, by the end of the 80s what did B&B have to show for their work in that decade on an international scale? Chess, that's all. I thought they were ambitious but they seemed to concentrate on Swedish artists and by the 90s they were writing a new musical in Swedish, which is something I never anticipated, although they probably had their personal reasons for doing so. Today, Sweden is well-known for providing songwriting and production services on an international level and I would have expected B&B to be part of that.
|
|
|
Post by richard on May 6, 2022 15:17:25 GMT
Had ABBA 'restarted', so to speak, in the 90s, I think the group would have been a wonderful means through which Benny could have tried different things, musically. But perhaps the Benny/Frida 'uncomfortablenes' stopped that even becoming a consideration. If it had happened, they might have lost a number of fans, but gained others. And if, subsequently, the Voyage concert idea still occurred, the setlist would, I'm sure, have been far wider than one consisting, mainly, of the old hits.
|
|
|
Post by undertheappletree on May 6, 2022 16:44:39 GMT
And here we are 40 plus years later, Abba are friends again, and gave us new music, kind of a fairly tale ending, Their music played constantly around the World to this day, and in London Soon to be three Separate Abba Shows, Mamma Mia The Musical, Mamma Mia The Party, and Voyage' and l believe this Month Universal are Showing ABBA The Movie' at the Cinema for a limited time. Abba are definitely Present.
|
|
|
Post by jj on May 6, 2022 16:54:30 GMT
i think i also have read some interviews wherein Benny would dismiss ABBA as music they did a long time ago (and this was in the 90s i think when they were active in Chess and Kristina). And I remember Frida also in the 90s advising fans to move on from ABBA since they were not ABBA anymore.
Your post brings into focus something most fans probably realise deep down, and that is that ABBA are still very much a thing of the past. They are still not an active group. Voyage serves just as a bonus bookend and it's not part of any natural flow or progression - not in the way each of their previous eight studio albums were when ABBA was indeed an active group. Instead, Voyage is an anomaly. It stands alone, far removed from the other albums they released between 1973 and 1981. ABBA, as they appear in 2021, is a "ghost group", and Voyage a zombie album. It's not a natural part of the group's progression for the simple reason that they ceased to be an active group in 1982. As it stands, ABBA still hasn't "come back" or reunited. Not to me, anyway. ABBA is still in the past. And I think the group members know and accept this, too, and have indeed all "moved on", despite their recent just-for-fun collaboration which gave us the album Voyage.
The Voyage project is actually quite upfront and honest about this, given its unabashed message is basically "It's ABBA, but also NOT ABBA".
Like it or not, the real ABBA ended in 1982.
|
|
|
Post by lamont on May 6, 2022 17:42:35 GMT
This is an interesting sub topic which does refer to Voyage! I recall reading that Benny & Bjorn thought Chess was taking too much of their time and formally shut the project down in early 90s. Perhaps ABBA was a really intense time for the members and they needed time away from the world. Gemini’s first album was a bit morose and theatrical, but the second had the same production aesthetics as anything from Michael Jackson & Madonna at the time. I remember in 1990 when Benny & Bjorn announced the Immigrants musical, it was major news in Sweden and it was revealed that Agnetha & Frida could sing on it, though Gorel said the name ABBA would not be used. The press travelled to Agnetha’s home to get a quote and she said “oh! Are the boys writing a new musical?” Which I think was a rather clever quote! Wrong footing the press. I think Benny enjoyed his folk time in late 80s and at one occasion Mona said he disappeared and he was out busking in the street with Orsa Spelman for charity, and anyone who donated got his autograph. Frida did distance herself too, writing that letter to fan clubs in 1987 and in a radio interview for Radio Sweden in 1992 she seemed not to understand the appeal of Bjorn Again or tribute acts (though one Swedish reporter said that it was probably because Frida was jealous of their dance routines.) also in 1992 when the revival kicked in, the Daily Express managed to get photos of Frida shopping in Fribourg, she asked the journalists not to blow her cover, but they told the shop owners, who were not really interested, but I think she realised she could live anonymously in Switzerland and public events in Sweden. The Voyage album is a welcome return for the group, but I feel it was Benny’s decision to return. Everyone else hinted at it over the years, but Benny being the maestro will have the final say.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 6, 2022 17:46:18 GMT
Some really interesting and valid points raised. Let's not forget " the reformed ABBA " are a lot older and maybe a little different. I think " hand on heart " " Voyage " will be their final studio output. JJ, I have a nagging thought that what you have said is true.
|
|
|
Post by lamont on May 6, 2022 17:49:54 GMT
i think i also have read some interviews wherein Benny would dismiss ABBA as music they did a long time ago (and this was in the 90s i think when they were active in Chess and Kristina). And I remember Frida also in the 90s advising fans to move on from ABBA since they were not ABBA anymore.
Your post brings into focus something most fans probably realise deep down, and that is that ABBA are still very much a thing of the past. They are still not an active group. Voyage serves just as a bonus bookend and it's not part of any natural flow or progression - not in the way each of their previous eight studio albums were when ABBA was indeed an active group. Instead, Voyage is an anomaly. It stands alone, far removed from the other albums they released between 1973 and 1981. ABBA, as they appear in 2021, is a "ghost group", and Voyage a zombie album. It's not a natural part of the group's progression for the simple reason that they ceased to be an active group in 1982. As it stands, ABBA still hasn't "come back" or reunited. Not to me, anyway. ABBA is still in the past. And I think the group members know and accept this, too, and have indeed all "moved on", despite their recent just-for-fun collaboration which gave us the album Voyage.
The Voyage project is actually quite upfront and honest about this, given its unabashed message is basically "It's ABBA, but also NOT ABBA".
Like it or not, the real ABBA ended in 1982.
Thing is, ABBA’s music is so timeless that Voyage is a natural progression on from The Visitors. It’s typical of ABBA that they don’t really play by the pop rule book! As Bjorn noted, who else has a 40 year gap between albums? I do think Voyage ABBA is different from Pop ABBA, in regards to it’s a different act, but Kate Bush & Bob Dylan are the same though. Bjorn did say he wished his fame was more like theirs, than the mega stardom they had early on. I think all members appreciate they can do ABBA without their privacy being compromised.
|
|
|
Post by Alan on May 6, 2022 18:15:55 GMT
Great post, jj. Every word.
|
|
|
Post by clumsylikeaclown on May 6, 2022 18:21:08 GMT
i think i also have read some interviews wherein Benny would dismiss ABBA as music they did a long time ago (and this was in the 90s i think when they were active in Chess and Kristina). And I remember Frida also in the 90s advising fans to move on from ABBA since they were not ABBA anymore.
Your post brings into focus something most fans probably realise deep down, and that is that ABBA are still very much a thing of the past. They are still not an active group. Voyage serves just as a bonus bookend and it's not part of any natural flow or progression - not in the way each of their previous eight studio albums were when ABBA was indeed an active group. Instead, Voyage is an anomaly. It stands alone, far removed from the other albums they released between 1973 and 1981. ABBA, as they appear in 2021, is a "ghost group", and Voyage a zombie album. It's not a natural part of the group's progression for the simple reason that they ceased to be an active group in 1982. As it stands, ABBA still hasn't "come back" or reunited. Not to me, anyway. ABBA is still in the past. And I think the group members know and accept this, too, and have indeed all "moved on", despite their recent just-for-fun collaboration which gave us the album Voyage.
The Voyage project is actually quite upfront and honest about this, given its unabashed message is basically "It's ABBA, but also NOT ABBA".
Like it or not, the real ABBA ended in 1982.
My opinion is probably quite similar to yours, but perhaps with a more optimistic slant. For years, I accepted what they said about the band never reforming and decided that 100 or so songs, most of them excellent, was more than enough. Then they said that they'd recorded two more. And then 'four or five'. And then it became a whole album. And to me, it was a delightful 'bonus' that I would never have expected. They're not the 'fantastic four' we once knew, but instead four separate individuals who have their own lives and interests who decided they may as well record some songs for 'old time's sake'. And that's beautiful in its own way. All I want to know is what specifically was the last song they recorded? Was it Ode to Freedom? Or one of the other tracks?
|
|
|
Post by HOMETIME on May 7, 2022 9:23:14 GMT
Absolutely. And we also need to remember that ABBA never really did the same thing twice. Each album was distinct from the last, so the idea of "Voyage" being some sort of long-lost son of "The Visitors" is unnecessary and off-brand. I think that a 1982/83 album might not have been wildly dissimilar to what we got in 2021. But, without the aid of a "What If" machine, we'll never know. Like clumsylikeaclown, I'd love to get some detail on the recording of the album - the chronology, the revisions, the challenges, the surprises. I know that the forthcoming CMP book focuses more on the promo/marketing end of things, but I wonder if the chapter(s) on "Voyage" might shed some light?
|
|
|
Post by manrockearth on May 7, 2022 9:51:44 GMT
Re the "VIP Opening Night" - many shows have a 'VIP' or "Press Night" preview the night before the "official" opening; Often reviews of a show often appear in the press on the day of the "official" opening night. On a fanclub webinar last week Ludvig Andersson stated all 4 members of ABBA had been invited and "It would be very rude of them not to attend" - whether they will stay for the 27th? - who can say? But you can bet the papers will be full of reviews on the morning of the 27th.
|
|
|
Post by undertheappletree on May 7, 2022 11:54:05 GMT
Voyage' Album is definitely ABBA it's a long time coming, but for me it is the follow up from The 'Vistors' they all agreed to form the Band and record a New Album. This was a few years ago, most fans realise they are not active now, The Album and Voyage' project that they Participated in together has Abba was finished for Them, as stated years ago.
Will they Release more ABBA Songs, only they Know, Benny has stated they have 2 More Abba Songs left over, needing more work. Frida said "Never Say Never" when asked if there would be more in the Future from Abba.
Will all four members attend the opening of Voyage" Show, l hope so, but that is their Choice to decide.
Will there be a third installment of the Mamma Mia Franchise Movie. I hope so, just to hear Benny's arrangements on the Soundtrack.
Will they one day release a Movie about Abba and their lives, maybe. Will ABBA Continue, yes in their Music.
|
|
|
Post by Alan on May 7, 2022 15:10:11 GMT
I honestly don’t know how I missed this, but I was just looking through Voyage photos and discovered that the album artwork states that Just A Notion was recorded at Polar Studios in 1978 and RMV Studios 2021. The Just A Notion artwork two weeks earlier merely stated 2017-2021. That means there are now six tracks we know the recording years for. ISHFIY, DSMD - 2017 ICBTW, B - 2019 LT, JAN (new backing track) - 2021 It appears to strengthen the case that JAN was drafted in to make up the numbers. Assuming they recorded a third track in 2019, that leaves three others for 2021.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 7, 2022 16:52:24 GMT
I still could imagine though that JAN was the "3rd Song" which was mentioned by Benny sometime in 2018 (or 2019). Could be that they didn't know at the time that Agnetha and Frida would be willing continue to record. And with JAN they had an additional Song which they could have produced/finalized without the help from Frida and/or Agnetha. I doubt the theory of producing JAN to make up 10 songs because a) the production of Voyage took more than 3 years and no one expected a whole album anyway, so they didn't have pressure to get 10 songs in short time?
|
|
|
Post by Jan on May 7, 2022 17:07:52 GMT
JAN should not have made the album given the vocals were recorded when they were in their prime. It is a fun song but only should have been on a compilation album as a new track. Surely they could have finished one of the 2 songs that Benny talked about to make the 10 track album complete.
|
|
|
Post by justabba on May 7, 2022 17:35:56 GMT
Apparently the unreleased song, hit by a train, was recorded in 2019 as well.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 7, 2022 18:14:07 GMT
It is interesting to read other members' views and comments regarding " Voyage " and ABBA as they are now. I agree it was a joy to hear they were composing and recording new songs. As Tony says every ABBA studio album is different to its predecessor. Their songs are uniquely different. " Voyage " is a stunning collection of tracks dealing with daily issues affecting anyone. The fact they can produce an album of high calibre in 2021 is amazing. We are all human and we all have our views and opinions.
|
|
|
Post by DaronJulian23 on May 7, 2022 18:34:24 GMT
While listening to Ode To Freedom. It just struck me how much this track reminds me of Hole In Your Soul.
Does anybody think else this or is it just me imagination?
|
|
|
Post by Alan on May 8, 2022 1:20:45 GMT
Apparently the unreleased song, hit by a train, was recorded in 2019 as well. Ooh, that’s interesting. Assuming “Hit By A Train” is metaphorical and not literal. We’d more likely say “hit me like a truck” though. Is there a leaked title for the other song as well? If this track was recorded in 2019, that means it could have been one of the long-rumoured five new songs (even if not completed). Could that mean that all four released songs that we don’t know the recording year for were recorded in 2021?
|
|
|
Post by Alan on May 8, 2022 1:31:45 GMT
I doubt the theory of producing JAN to make up 10 songs because a) the production of Voyage took more than 3 years and no one expected a whole album anyway, so they didn't have pressure to get 10 songs in short time? It’s likely there was a deadline, if the announcement was to be made on 2 September. It’s known that they were still recording very shortly before the announcement was made. If the two incomplete songs had both been abandoned, Just A Notion could have been brought in fairly late on. It was possibly there in reserve all along (as there was clearly a lot of unfinished business with the track) but I had assumed until Saturday that it had slowly been worked on all the way through. The 2021 date for the track in the album credits dispels that theory.
|
|
|
Post by justabba on May 8, 2022 7:25:56 GMT
Alan I think you are right in all of this. I understand there is a line in the song something like your first kiss hit me like a train or similar. I think Dan, ode, little things and no doubt must have been recorded in 2021, alongside the other unreleased track. ( sorry no title)
|
|
|
Post by Michal on May 8, 2022 9:06:50 GMT
...I feel it was Benny’s decision to return. Everyone else hinted at it over the years, but Benny being the maestro will have the final say. Maybe you're right, on the other hand, I would not say that we've waited forty years because Benny was not willing to do it before. I guess there were times when the return of ABBA was more or less seriously considered but there was always something in the way. I've read somewhere that they discussed the possible reunion in the early nineties. I guess it must have been Agnetha, who was against it back then, as she was going through a very difficult period and it was probably the time of her lowest ever interest in public life. More interesting is the question who blocked the billion dollar offer :-) Or was it a joint decision to make it absolutely clear that money was not the factor that could lure them back? But of course the problem was that they would have been required to actually tour and none of them was probably willing to do that.
|
|
|
Post by lamont on May 8, 2022 10:12:10 GMT
...I feel it was Benny’s decision to return. Everyone else hinted at it over the years, but Benny being the maestro will have the final say. Maybe you're right, on the other hand, I would not say that we've waited forty years because Benny was not willing to do it before. I guess there were times when the return of ABBA was more or less seriously considered but there was always something in the way. I've read somewhere that they discussed the possible reunion in the early nineties. I guess it must have been Agnetha, who was against it back then, as she was going through a very difficult period and it was probably the time of her lowest ever interest in public life. More interesting is the question who blocked the billion dollar offer :-) Or was it a joint decision to make it absolutely clear that money was not the factor that could lure them back? But of course the problem was that they would have been required to actually tour and none of them was probably willing to do that. I don’t think Benny consciously didn’t want ABBA to reform, I think he is a true artist and doesn’t compromise his art. Through the years I heard really positive quotes to ambiguous quotes from the other members, with Bjorn saying “of course”, Frida: “I’m just waiting for a call,” to Agnetha: “I’m not against it.” The stars aligned.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 8, 2022 11:06:46 GMT
It seemed that Agnetha was ready for a Reunion in 2014, but the others were reluctant...
|
|
|
Post by lamont on May 8, 2022 12:34:25 GMT
It seemed that Agnetha was ready for a Reunion in 2014, but the others were reluctant... It was all smoke & mirrors for years, I remember The Sun newspaper in 1988 saying that an “ABBA Summer Reunion.” Was on the cards, this created a flurry of excitement until a few days later they printed that it was Agnetha who was organising it and the Abba community felt so deflated as they knew it was false!
|
|